Arquitectura Viva
Sunday, January 26, 2020
04/01/2020

The Representation of Modernity

Luis Fernández-Galiano

Modern architecture was based on montage and the metropolis. This is the main point of the splendid work of the Swiss historian Martino Stierli, chief curator of architecture at the MoMA. With elegant prose and excellent illustrations, Stierli reconciles erudition and clarity to explain the confluence of architecture, photography, film, and the visual arts in the crucible of modernity, and explores the importance of montage through some episodes, from Paul Citroen’s Metropolis to Rem Koolhaas’s Delirious New York, which proposed to revamp urban historiography through a literary montage.

Inevitably, the two protagonists are Mies van der Rohe – whose photomontages of the Friedrichstrasse Skyscraper or the Museum for a Small City are part of the history of 20th-century architecture – and Serge Eisenstein, the Russian film director who theorized on montage in his field but also wrote on architecture and urban planning as pre-cinematographic media. When dealing with Eisenstein, the narrative discusses Le Corbusier and the promenade architecturale, and various sections also comment on Aby Warburg’s Mnemosyne Atlas, the visual assemblages of the books by Sigfried Giedion or André Malraux, Walter Benjamin’s textual collages, Colin Rowe and Fred Koetter’s Collage City, or Manfredo Tafuri‘s use of historiographic montages that make his works palimpsests.

Spanish readers will appreciate the space devoted to Eisenstein’s interest in El Greco, whose relationship with cinema he explored in various texts, and whose View and Plan of Toledo he considered an example of cinematographic montage; to José Ortega y Gasset’s Meditations on the Frame, where the philosopher relates the architectural window to the frames of canvases; or to the caustic demolition of Tafuri’s texts by Tomás Llorens, who attributed their incoherence and intelligibility to the above-mentioned montage of fragments by the Italian historian. In short, paraphrasing Erwin Panofsky, who said perspective was the ‘symbolic form’ of the Renaissance, Stierli asserts that the montage defines 20th-century Western visual culture, playing a central role until the current digital revolution.

In a book launched shortly after, the Yale art history professor Craig Buckley documents the role of montage in 1960s experimental architecture. Though more limited in scope, the text also deals with figures like Eisenstein, Giedion, or Mies, and similarly begins with clarification of the terms ‘montage,’ ‘collage,’ and ‘assembly,’ but enriches the panorama through the visionary proposals of Archigram, Buckminster Fuller, Hans Hollein, Yona Friedman, or the Situationists, the critical contributions of Reyner Banham or Martin Pawley, and the influence of artists like Richard Hamilton or Claes Oldenburg. Almost all these names are absent in Montage and the Metropolis. Buckley’s work does not compare with Stierli’s in theoretical ambition, nor in editing, but is a good complement, and both attest the renewed interest in montage within the academic community of historians of contemporary architecture.

Martino Stierli
Montage and the Metropolis
Yale U.P., New Haven, 2018
305 pages

Craig Buckley
Graphic Assembly
U. Minnesota P., Minneapolis 2019
390 pages

Arquitectura Viva 218
   

AV Monografías 220 - VECTOR ARCHITECTS AV Monographs
analyzes in each issue a theme related to a city, a country, a tendency or an architect, with articles by leading specialists complemented by commentary on works and projects illustrated in detail. Published bilingually, with Spanish and English texts placed side by side.
Arquitectura Viva 220 - TED’A ARQUITECTES Arquitectura Viva
covers current topics, taking stock of recent trends in set sections: cover story, works and projects, art and culture, books, technique and innovation. From 2013 on, monthly and bilingual, with Spanish and English texts printed side by side.
AV Proyectos 95 - ENSAMBLE STUDIO AV Proyectos
is the third member of the AV family: a bilingual publication essentially focussed on design projects (with special attention on competitions and construction details), heretofore only laterally dealt with in the other two magazines.
;
Editorial Arquitectura Viva SL - Calle de Aniceto Marinas, 32 - E-28008 Madrid, España - Ph: (+34) 915 487 317 - Fax: (+34) 915 488 191 - AV@ArquitecturaViva.com - Latest News in RSS